Why do I use local estate agents to sell properties? I’ve been buying, developing, and selling property for over fifteen years now. In that time I’ve worked with high-street agents, online agents, fixed-fee services, and I’ve even tried selling a couple of properties privately when the market was strong and I was confident about the buyer pool. I have strong views on this, formed through experience rather than theory, and I want to share them — because I think a lot of people, particularly other small developers and landlords, are making the same mistakes I made early on when I thought the agent’s commission was the most important number in the equation.
It isn’t. Not even close.
The First Time I Understood What a Good Local Agent Actually Does
The clearest example I can give happened about eight years ago. I’d finished a refurb on a three-bedroom Victorian terrace — bought at auction, stripped back, replumbed, rewired, new kitchen and bathrooms, the full works. Good job, well finished, fair asking price for the area.
I’d previously used a decent local agent on smaller projects. This time, partly because I’d heard good things and partly because I wanted to try something different, I used an online fixed-fee service. I paid about £800 upfront, got listed on Rightmove, and sat back.
Three weeks. No serious offers. A handful of viewings, mostly people who I could tell within five minutes were not in a position to buy. One cheeky offer about £20,000 below asking from someone who clearly thought the absence of agent-backed urgency was an invitation to test the floor. I turned it down. Week four, week five. Then I rang the local agent I’d used before.
He came to see the property. Walked around, looked at what I’d done. Said: “I’ve got a couple who have been looking for exactly this. Lost out on something similar three streets away last month. Can I call them tonight?”
He called them. They viewed the next day. Offer at asking price within 48 hours. Exchanged six weeks later.
The commission I paid him was approximately £5,500. That is an enormous number when you write it down. But the alternative — continuing to wait, potentially accepting that below-asking offer, or spending more weeks paying the mortgage on an unsold property — would have cost me more. And the speed of the exchange mattered because I had another purchase lined up that was time-sensitive.
I have never been casual about agent selection since that day.
What Local Estate Agents Have That National and Online Services Don’t
The thing I’ve come to understand about a genuinely good local estate agent is that their value is almost entirely in what they know that isn’t written down anywhere — the informal, accumulated, relational knowledge of a specific market.
They know who is looking. Not in the abstract database sense that any portal can serve, but specifically — by name, by requirement, by timeline, by frustration level. They know that a particular couple lost out on a property last month and are ready to move quickly on the right thing. Local estate agents know that a buy-to-let investor they placed six months ago has been talking about acquiring something in the same area. They know that a family who came to them for a valuation three months ago and decided not to sell at the time are now considering it — and they may have a buyer before that property is publicly listed.
This is intelligence. It’s the kind of intelligence that takes years to accumulate in a specific patch, and it simply does not exist in the same form at an online agent who covers the whole country or in a private seller who has one property to sell and no network.
I’ve had local agents call me about properties before they went live because they knew my brief. I’ve had the same agents call buyers on my behalf who weren’t on any active portal search. These are the conversations that produce sales faster and at better prices than waiting for Rightmove to do its algorithmic work.
So if you’re looking for property in the Ribble Valley area, for example, check out the leading estate agents Clitheroe has and work with someone local who knows the market and the area.
The Viewing Experience Matters More Than Developers Think
As a developer, I sometimes forget that the people buying my properties are not thinking about yield or return on cost or days on market. They are thinking about whether they could live there, whether it feels like the right place for their family, whether the kitchen is right for the way they cook. The emotional response to the property is everything.
I’ve learned — and it took me a while — that I am not the right person to conduct viewings on my own developments.
I know too much. I know where the original problems were, I know which details I had to compromise on, I know every imperfection because I was there when it happened. When a buyer asks about the area, I give them a developer’s answer when they want a resident’s answer. When they pause in a room and look uncertain, I feel the urge to address the uncertainty directly rather than letting the room make its case. I fill silences that should be left empty.
A good agent shows the property and then gets out of the way. They know which rooms to prioritise, they know how to read a buyer’s body language, they know when enthusiasm is genuine and when it’s polite. They come back with real feedback — not the sanitised version people give the seller, but the actual objections and hesitations that I can either address or use to recalibrate my expectations.
That feedback loop is worth more to me on the next development than the commission costs on this one.
Negotiation: The Part Where Amateurs Consistently Lose Money
I’ll be direct here because I’ve seen this happen to other developers and I’ve felt it myself: negotiating the sale of your own development, directly with the buyer, is one of the hardest situations to handle well even if you are a reasonably experienced businessperson in other contexts.
The problem is that you have too much invested. Not just financially — the time, the stress, the decisions that felt enormous when you made them, the weeks on site, the problems you solved. Sitting opposite a buyer who is trying to talk you down from asking price, who has just had a survey that lists every minor issue as if it’s a structural crisis, who is using silence and hesitation as leverage — that is a difficult room to be professional in when you are the person who built the thing.
A good agent is not in that room. They are on the telephone, professionally, reporting what the buyer is saying and what the buyer is offering, and then waiting for your instructions. Also, they translate between the buyer’s tactical negotiating language and the seller’s actual commercial position. They know which survey items are genuine and which are standard language. Also, they know what comparable sales justify at this moment. They know whether to push back hard or to concede a small amount now to hold the price on the larger issue.
I have never once regretted paying an agent’s commission after a negotiation. I have twice deeply regretted trying to negotiate a direct sale myself — once accepting an offer I didn’t need to accept because I was anxious about the market at the time, and once losing a buyer because I was too stiff in the negotiation because I was being emotional rather than commercial about the price.
The agent doesn’t have those problems. The agent is doing their job.
Sale Progression: What Happens After the Offer
People think selling a property is the hard part. It isn’t — not for a developer, anyway. Agreeing a sale is maybe a third of the story. What happens between offer accepted and exchange of contracts is where more sales fall apart than most sellers realise, and it is where a good agent earns a significant portion of their fee.
I’ve had sales fail at week twelve because the buyer’s mortgage offer came back below the agreed price and nobody managed the communication well enough to keep both parties at the table. Then I’ve had sales held up for six weeks because a solicitor on the buyer’s side wasn’t returning calls and nobody was chasing. Another time, I’ve had chains collapse because something three links away went wrong and I only found out about it when the buyer called to say they were pulling out.
A good local agent manages this process actively. They know the solicitors. Importantly, they know which ones are fast and which ones are slow. They know when to make a chasing call and when to wait. When the chain is under pressure they find out why, and they manage the information to keep everyone in the process working toward resolution rather than toward abandonment.
This isn’t glamorous work. It’s not the part of estate agency that gets written about or advertised. But it is operationally critical for a developer whose business model depends on cash flowing from completed sales to fund the next purchase. Time on the market after an agreed offer is money — interest on bridging, opportunity cost, overhead. Every week the sale drags is a real cost to me.
The Commission Arithmetic
I want to talk about the commission honestly because I think it is consistently misframed in the public conversation about estate agents.
On a £400,000 sale, a 1.25% plus VAT commission is £6,000 including VAT. That is a large number out of context. In the context of a development where my purchase, finance, and build costs might be £320,000, and where I’m targeting a profit of £60,000–£80,000, the commission is roughly 8–10% of my target profit. That is material and I want to make sure I’m getting value for it.
But the comparison is not commission versus nothing. The comparison is commission versus the cost of what I’m not getting if I don’t pay it: the pre-market buyer contact, the expert valuation, the viewing management, the feedback loop, the negotiation support, the progression management. These things have value that I can roughly quantify in terms of the difference between a quick, at-asking sale and a slow, below-asking one.
A sale that completes in eight weeks at asking price versus a sale that takes eighteen weeks at 3% below asking is not just a negotiation win. It is also ten weeks less of finance charges, ten weeks less of insurance and utilities on a vacant property, and ten weeks of my own time not being consumed by a sale that hasn’t closed. On a £400,000 property with bridging at 0.75% per month, ten weeks is approximately £6,750 in interest alone — more than the agent’s commission.
The commission isn’t the cost. The commission is the cost of the service, and the cost of the alternative (a slower, lower, more effortful private or online sale) is often higher.
What I Look For When I Choose a Local Agent
I don’t choose the agent with the lowest commission. I choose the agent who I believe will most effectively sell my specific property to the specific buyer it needs.
What that means in practice:
Track record in my postcode. Not the town, not the area — the postcode. How many properties have they sold in the last twelve months at the price range I’m working in? What did those properties achieve versus asking price? How long did they take from listing to exchange? This data is available if you ask for it.
Genuine local buyer knowledge. When I meet an agent for a valuation, I ask them who they think is looking for a property like this right now. A good agent has an answer that isn’t generic — they name the type of buyer, describe the dynamic they’ve been seeing, and ideally mention specific situations (without naming names) that illustrate active demand. An agent who gives me a vague answer about “strong buyer demand” is an agent who doesn’t know their patch.
Communication style. I want an agent who will call me with news, not send me a weekly email report. Next, I want to know about viewings, about offers, about problems — in real time. I need a business partner in the sale, not an administrative service.
Fee structure that aligns incentives. Completion-only commission means the agent is paid when the sale completes, not when it’s agreed. Their incentive is a completed transaction, which is exactly my incentive. I’m sceptical of arrangements that pay the agent regardless of outcome.
The agent I use most often now I found by asking another developer who they rated in the area. That personal recommendation, from someone whose commercial interests are aligned with mine, was more reliable than any review platform.
The Simple Version
If I had to reduce fifteen years of doing this to a single piece of advice about estate agents: the commission is the last thing to optimise. Optimise for the agent who knows your patch, who has the buyers you need, who can manage your sale to a completed exchange, and who will negotiate on your behalf with the skill and detachment that you yourself cannot bring to the table.
Everything else — the portal listing, the photography, the for-sale board — is infrastructure. The agent’s knowledge, relationships, and active management of your sale are the thing that can’t be replicated at a fixed fee.
Pay the commission. Get the right agent. Move on to the next project faster.
About the Author
